Commentary: November glut of school referendums signals necessity of taxing option in Virginia

If you wondered whether localities across Virginia desperately need another way to raise money to build new schools, take a look at the dozens of communities that will hold voter referendums in November. 

Cardinal News recently reported that more than 40 localities plan referendums this fall seeking a 1% sales tax increase for school construction and major renovations. Many of those school divisions are small and rural. Some are urban like Norfolk, Portsmouth and Newport News.

This is a Dillon Rule state, and some local taxes can’t be increased without the General Assembly’s blessing. Former Gov. Glenn Youngkin repeatedly vetoed similar sales tax legislation that reached his desk – his eyes more focused on his political future than fixing the state’s crumbling school buildings.

When current Gov. Abigail Spanberger signed the state budget this year, the tax increase clause – including a voter referendum – was part of the deal. The rest of the state will now enjoy an option that only nine localities previously had access to.

State lawmakers and education officials knew for years that school infrastructure statewide needed help. In 2021, the General Assembly’s own Commission on School Construction and Modernization placed the tab for new construction and major repairs at $25 billion for public K-12 buildings at least a half-century old. More than 1,000 Virginia public schools fit that category.

Recent news stories have noted the dire conditions and desired overhauls: HVAC and boiler upgrades in Franklin County. A layout design that isn’t as safe as it should be and an expensive roof replacement in Pulaski County. Broken pipes and busted air conditioning units in Newport News.

Money from the sales tax increase would put a dent in the bills for repairs and school-building.

In Norfolk, for example, “The City is estimating the additional annual revenue to be $40 million,” Kelly Straub, a city spokesperson, told me by email. The tax in Norfolk would expire in 2046.

It shouldn’t have taken so many years to give all localities this taxing tool. It would be no surprise if voters in many communities passed their referendums on Nov. 3.

This post was originally published on Virginia Mercury.

City National Bank BankAtCity.com

Two Fat Butchers
Family Owned & Operated Since 2007
540-635-6900
WarrenCountyVa.com/butcher

Hot Tub Heaven 540-636-1522

Complete Carpet Care 540-636-8718

Royal Oak Computers 540-635-7064

Aadvanced Driving Instruction 540-635-9015

Virginia Satsang Society
Local spiritual exploration
Open to all
WarrenCountyVa.com/eckankar

Woodbine Farm Market 540-465-2729
Farm to Market on Main Downtown Front Royal

Mountain Mystic 540-635-6318
On Second Thought 540-465-2655
Dusty’s Country Store 540-522-5083

Shenandoah Valley Golf Club 540-636-4653

BS Build/Remodel/Handyman 540-551-2673

Berryville Hardware True Value Berryville 540-955-1900

AireServ 540-551-8312
Dave’s Diversified Services 540-636-3396

Christoff Construction 703-895-7711

Sonus Technologies 540-364-6910

Hillbilly’s Bentonville Junkyard 540-636-2671

A1A Lawncare Services 540-636-9002
Pacific Landscaping 540-313-2721
Conway Lawn Care 540-975-2313

Belle Grove Plantation 540-869-2028
Cedar Creek Battlefield 540-869-2064

Shear Elegance 540-622-8085
Spicewood Flats 540-635-8979

Hamrick’s 540-631-0666
Peak Roofing Contractors 703-753-4585

Hidden Springs Senior Living 540-636-2008

Morrison Excavating
Frederick, Warren, Clarke areas
Richard Morrison 540-327-6716
WarrenCountyVa.com/septic

Tony’s Tires 540-551-0922

S&S Tobacco 540-622-6845

Dan McDermott 540-305-3000