Federal judge orders White House must restore press passes to 3 banned news outlets

WASHINGTON — U.S. District Court Judge Timothy Kelly early Thursday issued an order that temporarily blocks President Donald Trump’s ban of three news organizations from the White House.

Kelly, in the eight-page order, said that the White House must “immediately return, reinstate, and restore the White House ‘hard pass’ press credentials held by employees of CNN, MS NOW, and POLITICO that were revoked” Friday and over the weekend.

The White House, however, didn’t appear to be following the ruling as of 10 a.m. Eastern on Thursday, when attorneys representing the news organizations filed a brief asking the court to hold a videoconference meeting as soon as possible. 

“This morning journalists from each of CNN, MS NOW, and POLITICO attempted to enter the White House and were turned away. A Secret Service agent confiscated the hard pass of journalists from all three organizations,” they wrote. 

Micah Stopperich, director of White House press operations, declared in a court filing just before 12:30 p.m. Eastern that his team delivered the press badges to the entry gate at 9:55 a.m. Eastern to be distributed to members of the media who had them confiscated. 

Kelly’s order will continue for 14 days while the case continues to be fought in U.S. District Court for the District of Columbia. Trump is scheduled to welcome Chinese President Xi Jinping to the White House Thursday.

Although Trump has indicated he will appeal any court ruling on the matter, Kelly noted that temporary restraining orders are “generally unappealable.” He said he would schedule a hearing for motions for a preliminary injunction, which would last until the final outcome of the suit and could be appealed.

The case began Monday when the three news outlets sued the Trump administration for barring their reporters from entering the White House grounds. 

The news organizations asked the district court to grant them either a temporary restraining order or a preliminary injunction that would require the White House to return the press passes, allowing the journalists to work from the complex once again. 

Kelly, who was appointed by Trump during his first term, had heard arguments in the case on Wednesday and appeared skeptical at the time of Department of Justice arguments. In his ruling, he said it appeared likely that the news outlets would succeed with their claim that journalists were denied their due process rights before their passes were confiscated.

While the Department of Justice argued that earlier cases dealing with press access to the White House were wrongly decided in journalists’ favor, Kelly said that he was “bound by D.C. Circuit precedent, full stop,” referring to earlier rulings by the appeals court.

Kelly in his order also expressed doubt about Department of Justice arguments that the ban was in response to concerns about articles that dealt with national security or classified information, saying DOJ “offered little” to back up that contention. 

Some news articles cited by the administration as endangering national security were written by reporters who didn’t even have White House passes, he noted.

Trump did not mention national security in announcing the ban and “instead, he focused on the alleged lack of truthfulness and negativity of Plaintiffs’ reporting,” Kelly said. 

“For another—and simply put—the record lacks factual support for Defendants’ contention that the revocation of Plaintiffs’ hard passes will in fact protect national security or that national security will be endangered if the Court orders their passes reinstated while this litigation proceeds,” Kelly said. 

The White House did not immediately respond to a request for comment from States Newsroom. 

Theodore J. Boutrous, Jr., the lawyer for the news outlets, praised the decision. “This is a strong ruling vindicating freedom of the press, due process and the rule of law,” he said in a statement. “We greatly appreciate the court’s swift action.”

Jennifer Shutt and Ashley Murray contributed to this report. 

This post was originally published on Virginia Mercury.

City National Bank BankAtCity.com

Two Fat Butchers ✓
Family Owned & Operated Since 2007
540-635-6900
WarrenCountyVa.com/butcher

Hot Tub Heaven 540-636-1522

Complete Carpet Care 540-636-8718

Royal Oak Computers 540-635-7064

Aadvanced Driving Instruction 540-635-9015

Virginia Satsang Society ✓
Local spiritual exploration
Open to all
WarrenCountyVa.com/eckankar

Woodbine Farm Market 540-465-2729
Farm to Market on Main Downtown Front Royal

Mountain Mystic 540-635-6318
On Second Thought 540-465-2655
Dusty’s Country Store 540-522-5083

Shenandoah Valley Golf Club 540-636-4653

BS Build/Remodel/Handyman 540-551-2673

Berryville Hardware True Value Berryville 540-955-1900

AireServ 540-551-8312
Dave’s Diversified Services 540-636-3396

Christoff Construction 703-895-7711

Sonus Technologies 540-364-6910

Hillbilly’s Bentonville Junkyard 540-636-2671

A1A Lawncare Services 540-636-9002
Pacific Landscaping 540-313-2721
Conway Lawn Care 540-975-2313

Belle Grove Plantation 540-869-2028
Cedar Creek Battlefield 540-869-2064

Shear Elegance 540-622-8085
Spicewood Flats 540-635-8979

Hamrick’s 540-631-0666
Peak Roofing Contractors 703-753-4585

Hidden Springs Senior Living 540-636-2008

Morrison Excavating ✓
Frederick, Warren, Clarke areas
Richard Morrison 540-327-6716
WarrenCountyVa.com/septic

Tony’s Tires 540-551-0922

S&S Tobacco 540-622-6845

Dan McDermott 540-305-3000