Commission explains shift in data center tax break estimate

(The Center Square) – State analysts are crediting Virginia’s data center tax break with attracting less business than earlier calculations assumed, a change they say reflects new research on those incentives across states.

In a followup response to The Center Square, the Joint Legislative Audit and Review Commission explained the calculation behind its estimated 22-cent return. The agency said it did not calculate returns using its earlier assumptions or model a range of estimates for the report.

The exemption provided an average of $811.5 million a year in state tax savings from fiscal 2021 through 2025, according to the commission’s report. The report estimated that business activity attracted by the exemption generated $179.4 million a year in state revenue, or 22 cents per dollar in tax savings.

Under Virginia law, qualifying data center operators and tenants can buy or lease computer equipment and enabling software without paying sales and use tax. They must meet investment, employment and wage requirements.

The Audit and Review Commission’s latest report credits the exemption with attracting 50.2% of data center activity in Virginia. Earlier reports assumed 90% or 100%, Ellen Miller, the commission’s chief economic development and quantitative analyst, told The Center Square.

Miller said earlier reports used economist Timothy Bartik’s method because no data center-specific research was available.

That method compares the size of an incentive with a company’s operating costs to estimate how strongly taxes influence where the company locates, she said. Larger incentives are more likely to influence that decision.

Because Virginia’s exemption is large, that method produced the higher estimates of how much activity it attracted, Miller said.

For the latest analysis, Miller said the commission used a peer-reviewed study estimating the average effect of state sales and use tax exemptions on data center numbers, square footage and energy use across states.

“The estimated return depends directly on how much data center activity is attributed to the exemption,” Miller told The Center Square.

Crediting the exemption with attracting twice as much activity would produce an estimated return about twice as high, she said.

Neil Osnato, founder of Persistence Analytics Group LLC, said lawmakers should ask the Audit and Review Commission to compare the estimated returns under the earlier 90% assumption and the current 50.2% figure, using the same methodology and other inputs.

“Before lawmakers act on the 22-cent figure, they should know what happens when those assumptions are tested,” Osnato told The Center Square.

He said he was taking no position on keeping or eliminating the exemption.

In an Oct. 28 response included in the report, Jason El Koubi, president and CEO of the Virginia Economic Development Partnership, said the revised assumption “materially impacts” the estimates. He encouraged continued evaluation as Virginia-specific evidence becomes available.

El Koubi also highlighted the exemption’s economic benefits, which the report ranked second to grants. The Audit and Review Commission estimated that the exemption supported an annual average of 18,130 private-sector jobs.

A separate Audit and Review Commission study published in 2024 counted about 150 data center sites containing roughly 340 buildings statewide. That study found about 80% of the industry concentrated in Loudoun, Prince William and Fairfax counties.

The exemption was a sticking point in this year’s budget negotiations. The adopted budget preserved it and added a temporary tax on data center electricity use through June 30, 2028.

The budget also directed the Joint Subcommittee on Tax Policy to review the exemption and other effects of data center development, with recommendations due to the General Assembly by Dec. 15.

The Audit and Review Commission’s report says its revenue analysis excludes local tax collections and changes in state or local government spending.

This post was originally published on The Center Square.

City National Bank BankAtCity.com

Two Fat Butchers ✓
Family Owned & Operated Since 2007
540-635-6900
WarrenCountyVa.com/butcher

Hot Tub Heaven 540-636-1522

Complete Carpet Care 540-636-8718

Royal Oak Computers 540-635-7064

Aadvanced Driving Instruction 540-635-9015

Virginia Satsang Society ✓
Local spiritual exploration
Open to all
WarrenCountyVa.com/eckankar

Woodbine Farm Market 540-465-2729
Farm to Market on Main Downtown Front Royal

Mountain Mystic 540-635-6318
On Second Thought 540-465-2655
Dusty’s Country Store 540-522-5083

Shenandoah Valley Golf Club 540-636-4653

BS Build/Remodel/Handyman 540-551-2673

Berryville Hardware True Value Berryville 540-955-1900

AireServ 540-551-8312
Dave’s Diversified Services 540-636-3396

Christoff Construction 703-895-7711

Sonus Technologies 540-364-6910

Hillbilly’s Bentonville Junkyard 540-636-2671

A1A Lawncare Services 540-636-9002
Pacific Landscaping 540-313-2721
Conway Lawn Care 540-975-2313

Belle Grove Plantation 540-869-2028
Cedar Creek Battlefield 540-869-2064

Shear Elegance 540-622-8085
Spicewood Flats 540-635-8979

Tana Hoffman 540-671-1994
Ken Thurman 540-749-2613
Team Daniels 540-683-7550
Aletha Craig 540-671-0466
Jen Avery 540-683-0790
Rocco Christoff 703-895-7711
Kayla Walraven 540-660-1632

Hamrick’s 540-631-0666
Peak Roofing Contractors 703-753-4585

Hidden Springs Senior Living 540-636-2008

Morrison Excavating ✓
Frederick, Warren, Clarke areas
Richard Morrison 540-327-6716
WarrenCountyVa.com/septic

Tony’s Tires 540-551-0922

S&S Tobacco 540-622-6845

Dan McDermott 540-305-3000